Featured Images - women reading. Image from Pixabay

Why you need to have Beta Readers

Beta Readers are an important resource for writers that can help strengthen your WIP.  So I thought I would go over some points regarding getting some beta readers.

NB: Thanks for all the comments, faves, followers and reblogs – sorry I’ve not been replying. I have no internet in my new house yet. (All these posts are scheduled.)  I’ll reply to you all as soon as I can!

DividerLine-Bold

What are Beta Readers?

Beta readers are people you recruit to read your unpublished work in order to suggest improvements, catch errors, and give you a “reader” perspective.

Writers are too close to their work and no matter how many edits you put your work through (and it should be several!) you will always need another pair (or several pairs) of eyes to check over it.

Beta Readers are typically avid readers of your specific genre and do this as a voluntary (ie unpaid) task to help the writer.

DividerLine-Bold

What’s the difference between Beta Readers & Critique Partners?

Beta Readers are usually specifically readers so they will read your manuscript as a reader.

A Critique Partner is normally a writer so will read your manuscript as a writer as well as a reader.

This different perspective can be helpful for catching deeper issues that a reader might not notice or might not realise how to fix.

A Beta Reader can be a writer and just do a “Beta Read” rather than a deeper “Critique” on the story.

DividerLine-Bold

Why you need Beta Readers?

Beta readers are invaluable as they can give you insights into your story that you may have missed.

As writers, we know an extensive amount of backstory, history, and detail about our characters, plot, worlds… so there may be times we “assume” our readers know something that we’ve not been clear about.

Beta readers are fresh eyes on our WIPs, they will catch where the story stumbles, where the dialogue is stilted, where a plot hole is gaping.  Their purpose is to spot significant flaws in your work.

They are also great for giving you a clearer idea of just how well your book will be received.

This is especially important if you are aiming for a specific age group like Middle school or YA.

Also, if you are self-publishing, you will need to pay for a professional editor.  If these people can catch issues before you send to an editor, it will save you some money.  Please note, Betas are NOT a substitute for a professional editor.

DividerLine-Bold

How many Beta Readers should you have?

I would personally recommend at a minimum of 3 to 5 beta readers.  The more beta readers you have the clearer issues can be located.  As if several of your betas pull up the same problems, you can see it’s a major issue that needs to be addressed.

Obviously, you don’t want so many that you struggle to keep up with all their recommendations as you will need to get details from each of them.

Go for quality over quantity, you want good, honest, genuine beta readers and it’s better to have just 4 or 5 of them than 20 betas who won’t give you a good critique.

DividerLine-Bold

When should you recruit Beta Readers?

Beta readers should be recruited, in my opinion, no earlier than after your fourth edit.  They are NOT Alpha Readers so should not be receiving a rough draft of your work.

They should be reading a pretty clean draft, catching the odd spelling error, and making suggestions about details.  Not doing a full edit for you.

Beta readers should also be brought in BEFORE the professional editor.

DividerLine-Bold

What is the process for Beta Readers?

Genre

Be very clear and specific on your genre.  I was once asked to beta read a science fiction WIP.  However, when I received it, the story was definitely designed for children so I was not the target audience and couldn’t complete it.

So pare down in your genre.  For example, when looking for betas for my Dark Hart WIP, I will make sure they know it’s a Preternatural (contains things beyond natural eg monsters, magic etc), Urban (modern day) Fantasy.

Age Range

Confirm your targeted age range.  For example, Children, Middle School, Young Adult, New Adult, Adult.  Many adults read YA and many teenagers read Adult, but you need to make sure your betas know what age range your book is aimed at.

Clear Guidelines

Every author is different in what they want from a beta reader.  Some want their betas to only focus on larger issues, such as continuity, dialogue, character and plot development.

Others want them to catch anything they see so that would be the bigger stuff as per above as well as smaller things such as spelling and grammar issues, incorrect punctuation etc.

Let your betas know ahead of time what you want from them.  Be specific.

Things you may want your betas to consider:

  • The pacing of the story
  • Strength of descriptions
  • Personality of characters
  • Action and conflict
  • Areas that are unclear or that left them feeling confused
  • What they loved
  • What they hated
  • Whether the world was detailed enough

These are just a few things you might want to ask them to think about.

Not every beta will automatically consider pacing or point of view, so if these are areas you want to check on, tell them.

Let them know if you will be asking them questions/sending them questions.

Encourage positive and negative

The point of betas is to pinpoint issues in your writing that need to be addressed.  However, don’t be afraid to ask them to mark up areas they really enjoyed, whether that was a strong piece of description or a shocking action scene or funny character interaction.

Firstly, it helps to know where your strengths are and secondly, it’s not easy to read a lot of notes stating issues with your work.  Having it broken up with some positive comments can make all the difference.

Decide on Format

Be clear on how you want their notes.  Do you want them to read a chapter and then write a detailed notes section about what they thought?  Do you want them to mark up with comments at the specific areas what they recommend?

Figure out what works for you.

The way I beta read is, I have the chapters sent separately and in PDF form, I then insert highlighted comments on the areas as they appear.

I include questions if I feel something seems wrong or doesn’t fit right.  Other times I may make a suggestion on how to include say, a different sense in description or highlight a repetitive work.

Organise a time frame

Beta reading takes time.  It’s not just reading, it’s analysing and making notes so it takes longer than it would to just “read” a novel.

Give your betas a good time frame to work on and check with them beforehand to see what sort of time they have.

I like getting WIPs in blocks of 3 chapters so I don’t feel overwhelmed and usually don’t take on a beta read that has a deadline of under a month.

DividerLine-Bold

Where to find Beta Readers?

I would personally recommend choosing betas from people you know – I’m not talking friends and family unless they are actually your target audience and will be honest.

I mean people you know in the writing community.  Don’t know anyone in the writing community?  Then make an effort to join.  Connect with people for a while before asking anyone to beta.

You are letting people into a very personal part of your life so you want people you can trust, people who really want to help and support you.

There are groups on Facebook where betas can be found, and you can always set up a message on your social media asking for betas.

Remember, don’t just accept anyone as a beta – connect with people for a while, ask them questions, get to know them a little before you accept them as betas.  Don’t just give your WIP to anyone who asks to be a beta.

DividerLine-Bold

Finally, additional things to consider

Delays

Beta reads can pull up larger issues you may not have realised that might mean a big overhaul of the plot or a lot of rewriting.  This is not a reason to skip the beta read phase but should be something you’re aware of in your time frame.

Unhelpful Betas

Not all betas may be helpful to you.  There will be some who may want to please you or who feel uncomfortable being honest and will not give you the critique you need.

There will be some that may offer no real critique and instead just say things like “boring” or “don’t like this character” or “I hate the name Jeff” etc.  Vague comments or subjective opinions aren’t helpful.

In these situations, you either need to confirm the beta is aware of the guidelines and what you need from them, or you need to let them go as they aren’t serving your needs.

NEW slim banner-Newsletter-SMALL

Security

There is a risk when you send your WIP to others, there have been reports of unscrupulous people who have shared writers’ work online.

There are things you can do to reduce the risk – the first is, as I mentioned, why you need to connect and know your betas before you share your work with them.

Give only a few chapters at a time rather than sending the whole WIP.

You can change a single thing in each copy.  For example, if you have a secondary character, you change the name so that each beta receives a WIP that has a different name for that character.  Then if someone does share your WIP, you can easily identify who did it.

If the idea really bothers you, you could always get your betas to sign an NDA (Non-disclosure agreement) confirming they will not share your WIP.  Though you shouldn’t need to go to such a level if you take the time to get to know your betas beforehand.

What has your experience been with beta readers?

Share your Thoughts image.

Happy writing

Signature & logo of Ari Meghlen

Ko-Fi ☆ TwitterFacebookInstagram ☆ GoodReadsPinterestLinkedInTumblr

Why you need to have Beta Readers.  Image: people reading

29 comments

    1. 😀 Glad you found this article useful, especially that part. It’s sad that we sometimes have to worry about people passing our work around without our permission, but small things like this can at least help us to track down who did it.

  1. Wonderful post Ari, I’m lucky enough to have worked with you as my beta reader. All your points are excellent and have helped me to become a better beta reader too. Although, after reading this I think you and I are classified as more critique partners. 💜💜 Thanks ffor all you guidance and support.

    1. Thanks Lorraine, aww yes it’s been so much fun being your BR/CP. I’m looking forward to sending you my scenes… when I finally finish them lol

  2. This is one of your best writer info posts. 😃
    I have pretty much only had my hubby – who is very much able to be honest with me – and my now gone book coach/editor Mary do beta reading for me. If I ever do write another book, I think I will look into finding two new people as well as keeping my hubby. (Always keeping him as my hubby! 😍) At this point I’m feeling very uncertain that I’ll be able to write up to my previous standards, so it would be most helpful to get some readers’ opinions so I don’t try to put out something that isn’t good.

    1. Aww thank you Pearl 😊

      It’s God you have your husband, sorry about Mary. I hope you do write again and I’m sure beta readers would be a great help 😊

  3. lots of good advice Ari. i am very lucky to have a weekly critique group. we meet to give each other feedback on a couple of pages of our WIP. this is a good place to find Beta Readers and also Proof Readers. we definitely need lots of feedback from people who read books. is the story working? does the ending work? does the first para draw us in? all good stuff.

    1. Thanks for reading Libby, sorry for the delay. A weekly critique group sounds great, I’ve got a few friends who have groups like that and have had nothing but good things to say. Do you meet in person or online?

  4. Asking for positive feedback, in addition to the negative stuff, is really important in my experience. There have been a few times when I was thinking about cutting something, but then betas would tell me they really liked that part, so I kept it.

    1. Thanks for reading, sorry for the delay. Yes definitely, positive feedback is a must as it helps us know what’s working and where our strengths are.

      I’ve had moments like that, where parts I was not sure about turned out to be firm favourites.

Leave a Reply to Libby Sommer Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.